Tracey L. (Yanusz) Taylor v. John J. Yanusz

This appeal involves a dispute over the custody of a five-year-old boy. His parents were divorced following his mother's extramarital affair. Their marital dissolution agreement established a joint custody arrangement with the father having primary physical custody. Following an unsuccessful two-year reconciliation effort, the child's mother petitioned the Sumner County General Sessions Court for sole custody. The father insisted that the child's circumstances had not changed and that he continued to be more fit than the mother to be the child's primary custodian. The trial court, sitting without a jury, determined that the child's circumstances had changed and that the child's interests would be best served by placing him in his mother's custody. The father asserts on this appeal that the child's circumstances have not changed materially and that the evidence does not support giving sole custody to the mother. While we have determined that the child's circumstances changed following his parents' divorce, we have determined that the evidence preponderates against the trial court's conclusion that the changes are so escalating and dangerous that they required a change in the original custody arrangement. Accordingly, we vacate the order awarding the mother sole custody of the child and remand the case for further proceedings.