Chancellor Carol L. McCoy of Nashville has been appointed to the commission responsible for evaluating state appellate court judges, including members of the Tennessee Supreme Court, and recommending to voters whether they should be retained in office or removed.
McCoy, of the 20th Judicial District, Davidson County, is one of six new members appointed to the Tennessee Judicial Evaluation Commission. Other members appointed by the state Judicial Council are Chancellors Telford E. Forgety, Jr. of the 4th and 5th Judicial Districts, including Cocke, Grainger, Jefferson, Sevier and Blount counties, and Howell N. Peoples of the 11th Judicial District, Hamilton County; Criminal Court Judge J.C. McLin of the 30th Judicial District, Shelby County; and Henrietta Grant, manager of community relations for the Knoxville Utility Board. Nashville attorney John Day was appointed by Lt. Gov. John Wilder. Terms of the new members are for six years.
The 12-member commission, created by the General Assembly, evaluates the performance of incumbent appellate court judges and makes recommendations to voters either “for retention” or “against retention.” By state law, the five Supreme Court justices, 12 members of the Court of Appeals and 12 members of the Court of Criminal Appeals are evaluated every eight years and re sults are published in newspapers across the state.
All judicial terms in Tennessee are eight years. When a mid-term vacancy occurs on an appellate or trial court, the state Judicial Selection Commission interviews applicants and recommends up to three candidates to the governor, who appoints a new judge to fill the unexpired term until the next August general election.