Kenneth W. Mitchell, et al., v. Homer E. Chance, et al.

Case Number
M2002-01239-COA-R3-CV

This appeal involves a dispute between neighbors regarding the use of a county road in rural Humphreys County. After one of the landowners began to use the road to cross the neighboring landowners' property, the neighboring landowners erected barricades in the road and later filed a trespass action in the Chancery Court for Humphreys County. The landowners who desired to use the road counterclaimed to establish their right of way along the road. Following a bench trial, the trial court sided with the landowners desiring to use the road. On this appeal, the landowners who desire to prevent the use of the road take issue with the trial court's refusal to consider parol evidence regarding the meaning of the references to the road in the deeds. We affirm the trial court's decision that the references to the road in the deeds are not ambiguous, as well as its decision to admit extrinsic evidence to determine the location of the road. We have also determined that the evidence fully supports the trial court's decision regarding the location and dimensions of the road.

Authoring Judge
Judge William C. Koch, Jr.
Originating Judge
Judge Robert E. Burch
Case Name
Kenneth W. Mitchell, et al., v. Homer E. Chance, et al.
Date Filed
Dissent or Concur
No
Download PDF Version
Mitchelk.pdf206.54 KB