Caitlin J. Groves, Et Al. v. Tennessee Department of Safety And Homeland Security

Case Number
M2016-01448-COA-R3-CV

After his vehicle was seized, the owner filed a claim and request for hearing. After the passage of thirty days following the filing of his claim, the owner moved to dismiss the forfeiture, arguing that the Tennessee Department of Safety and Homeland Security had failed to timely set his claim for a hearing. The Administrative Law Judge took the motion to dismiss under advisement, but declined to set a hearing on the merits of the forfeiture. The owner sought interlocutory review of the decision not to set a hearing on the merits, which the Commissioner ultimately denied. Shortly before the Commissioner’s decision on the interlocutory appeal, the ALJ granted the owner’s motion to dismiss and ordered the vehicle returned. The ALJ also denied the owner’s request for attorney’s fees. The owner petitioned for judicial review of the Commissioner’s decision and later amended the petition to include a request for declaratory relief. The chancery court dismissed the owner’s petition for judicial review as moot. The court also dismissed the declaratory judgment action for improper joinder of an original action with an administrative appeal. We affirm.

Authoring Judge
Judge W. Neal McBrayer
Originating Judge
Chancellor Russell T. Perkins
Case Name
Caitlin J. Groves, Et Al. v. Tennessee Department of Safety And Homeland Security
Date Filed
Dissent or Concur
No
Download PDF Version