Donna Faye Shipley, et al. v. Robin Williams - Concurring

Case Number
M2007-01217-SC-R11-CV

I concur in the majority opinion but write separately to address the dissenting opinion’s assertion that the “sky is falling.” The majority opinion has not substantially altered “the standard of review of summary judgments based on the inadmissibility of evidence relating to an essential element of the nonmoving party’s case.” Despite Justice Koch’s statements to the contrary, after the release of this opinion, appellate courts will continue to review evidentiary determinations using an abuse of discretion standard. Stating otherwise does not advance this discussion.

Authoring Judge
Justice Janice M. Holder
Originating Judge
Judge Barbara N. Haynes
Case Name
Donna Faye Shipley, et al. v. Robin Williams - Concurring
Date Filed
Dissent or Concur
This is a dissenting opinion
Download PDF Version