Cletus M. Thetford v. American Manufacturers Mutual Insurance Company, et al. - Dissenting

Case Number
W2003-01904-SC-WCM-CV

I respectfully dissent from the opinion filed by the other members of the Panel.

Mr. Thetford had a pre-existing arthritic condition. I find the evidence presented in this case preponderates against a finding that his pre-existing condition was advanced and anatomically changed by his work for Tower.

Authoring Judge
Senior Judge James L. Weatherford
Originating Judge
Chancellor George R. Ellis
Case Name
Cletus M. Thetford v. American Manufacturers Mutual Insurance Company, et al. - Dissenting
Date Filed
Dissent or Concur
This is a dissenting opinion
Download PDF Version