Wilson v. Coppinger Color Lab

This workers' compensation appeal has been referred to the Special Workers' Compensation Appeals Panel of the Supreme Court in accordance with Tenn. Code Ann. _ 5-6-225(e)(3) for hearing and reporting to the Supreme Court of findings of fact and conclusions of law. This appeal has resulted from a finding by the trial court that plaintiff, Constance H. Wilson, sustained a compensable injury while in the employment of her last employer, Telecable. The trial court dismissed the case against the former employer, Coppinger Color Lab, Inc., and held Travelers Insurance Company liable as the insurance carrier for the last employer. The only issue is whether the Last Injurious Injury Rule applies so as to hold the last employer liable for the compensable claim. Plaintiff, age 41 years, began working for Coppinger Color Lab, Inc. during August 1986. She worked eight years before leaving to take a job with Telecable. During her eight year period of employment, she did data entry work with a computer. She estimated that this type of work activity consumed about 85-9% of her time. During the last two years of employment, she started having problems with numbness in both hands. Her condition continued to get worse and she testified the numbness and tingling was almost a daily event. However, she continued to work. Plaintiff went to work for Telecable, her last and present employer, on June 1, 1994 and was employed as a dispatcher which involved computer work to a lesser extent than in her former employment. She stated she did this type of work about 25-5% of the time. The first two weeks of this new job was a training period that required her to watch another employee most of the time. While working she continued to have the same problem with her hands and wrists. During the last part of June 1994 she awoke during the night with severe pain in her left arm between her elbow and wrist which she described as being worse than any pain she had ever encountered before. This scared her and she decided to see a doctor. She continued to work and during her last year of employment, she received a promotion to a job classified as an administrative assistant. Her condition began to improve but the medical evidence is quite clear that she needs to have surgery for bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome injury. 2