Duell Wayne West v. Vought Aircraft Industries, Inc., et al. and Terry Thompson v. Peterbilt Motor Company and/or Paccar Inc.

Case Number
M2007-01904-SC-R9-WC

We granted review of these workers’ compensation cases to decide when a case becomes “pending” for purposes of the prior suit pending doctrine. We conclude that a lawsuit becomes “pending” when the complaint is filed. Although the filing of the complaint initiates the pendency of  the case, a subsequent case will be subject to dismissal under the prior suit pending doctrine only if the court in the prior case has acquired personal jurisdiction over the parties. Accordingly, the lawsuit filed by the employer in West v. Vought Aircraft Industries, Inc. was entitled to priority, and the employee’s lawsuit is remanded to the trial court for dismissal. The employee’s lawsuit in Thompson v. Peterbilt Motor Co. has been rendered moot and is dismissed.

Authoring Judge
Justice Janice M. Holder
Originating Judge
Judge John D. Wootten, Jr.
Case Name
Duell Wayne West v. Vought Aircraft Industries, Inc., et al. and Terry Thompson v. Peterbilt Motor Company and/or Paccar Inc.
Date Filed
Dissent or Concur
This is a dissenting opinion
Download PDF Version