State of Tennessee v. James Alvin Castleman - Dissenting

Case Number
W2009-01661-CCA-R3-CD

The majority opinion correctly sets out the posture of this case, and I will not restate it. However, I write to dissent from the majority’s opinion because I feel that the facts of this case clearly establish that an illegal judgment of conviction was entered against the defendant and, as such, should not now stand to allow him to be convicted of the very crime that the Tennessee trial court failed to warn him of. In this case, the blatant fundamental unfairness is obvious and, in my opinion, clearly rises to the level of a due process violation.

Authoring Judge
Judge John Everett Williams
Case Name
State of Tennessee v. James Alvin Castleman - Dissenting
Date Filed
Dissent or Concur
This is a dissenting opinion
Download PDF Version