John M. Hollis, individually and as the Surviviing Parent of Raven BLair Hollis, v. W. Charles Doerflinger, Administrator ad Litem for the Estate of Rhonda B. Hollis, et al.

Case Number
M2002-00222-COA-R3-CV

This is an insurance case. The mother and the father were covered by an automobile insurance policy that excluded coverage for certain family members who were residents of the same household as the insureds. The mother was pregnant with a viable fetus. She was at fault in an automobile accident in which she and the fetus died. On behalf of the deceased fetus, the father filed a wrongful death action against the mother's estate. On a motion for partial summary judgment, the father sought a declaratory judgment to determine whether the insurance company was obligated to provide coverage for the deceased fetus. The trial court found that the insurance policy's family exclusion provision was ambiguous. Consequently, it construed the policy in favor of the father, finding that the fetus was not considered a resident of the father's household and that the insurance company was required to provide coverage for the deceased fetus. After a trial, the father was awarded damages plus prejudgment interest. The insurance company and the administrator ad litem of the mother's estate appeal. The insurance company argues that the fetus was excluded from coverage. The administrator ad litem of the mother's estate asserts that the trial court erred in awarding prejudgment interest. We reverse, finding that the fetus was a resident of the mother's household, and consequently a resident of the father's household, and that the insurance company was therefore not obligated to provide coverage for the fetus. The award of prejudgment interest is reversed as well.

Authoring Judge
Judge Holly Kirby Lillard
Originating Judge
Judge Stella L. Hargrove
Case Name
John M. Hollis, individually and as the Surviviing Parent of Raven BLair Hollis, v. W. Charles Doerflinger, Administrator ad Litem for the Estate of Rhonda B. Hollis, et al.
Date Filed
Dissent or Concur
No
Download PDF Version
hollis.pdf28.34 KB