Rita Faye Hurst v. Claiborne County Hospital and Nursing Home et al.

Case Number
E2017-01598-SC-R3-WC

An employee sued for workers’ compensation benefits alleging two distinct injuries on different dates: physical injuries sustained in a work-related motor vehicle collision in 2001 and mental injuries from an incident involving a severely abused infant in 2000. The employee settled her mental injury claim. The trial court’s judgment approving the settlement included future medical benefits for the employee’s mental injuries, but none for physical injuries related to the collision. Nine years later, the employee filed a motion to compel medical benefits for her physical injuries related to the collision. The trial court, in an order referencing this case (#13,393) and a later-filed case (#15,665), ordered the employer to provide medical benefits for the employee’s physical injuries. In a separate order, the trial court awarded the employee her attorney fees and costs. We vacate the trial court’s orders, finding that the trial court did not have subject matter jurisdiction to compel medical benefits for the employee’s physical injuries.

Authoring Judge
Justice Sharon Lee
Originating Judge
Judge Elizabeth C. Asbury
Case Name
Rita Faye Hurst v. Claiborne County Hospital and Nursing Home et al.
Date Filed
Dissent or Concur
No