James Michael Richardson v. A. O. Smith Company
02S01-9804-CH-00039
Authoring Judge: F. Lloyd Tatum, Special Judge
Trial Court Judge: Hon. George R. Ellis, Chancellor
This workers' compensation appeal was referred to the Special W orkers' Compensation Appeals Panel of the Supreme Court pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. _5-6- 225(e)(3) (Supp. 1998) for hearing and reporting to the Supreme Court of findings of fact and conclusions of law. This case was tried on February 24, 1998. The chancellor found that there was no period of temporary total disability, but awarded the plaintiff fifteen percent (15%) permanent partial disability to the whole body as a result of a work-related accident in December 1988 or January 1989. Defendant, A. O. Smith Company, has appealed the chancellor's decision as not supported by a preponderance of the evidence. After careful review, we find that the judgment of the trial court must be reversed. At the time of trial, the Plaintiff, James Michael Richardson, testified that he was a 5-year-old man with a high school education and vocational training as an industrial electrician. His post-high school employment experience involved mostly electrical work. He was subsequently employed by the defendant as an electrical, mechanical maintenance man and was working as an appraiser for an insurance adjusting company at the time of trial. He recounted the events surrounding his back injury as follows. In late December of 1988 or early January of 1989, the plaintiff felt "a hurting" in his lower back while helping another employee lift a 25-horsepower electric motor onto a stand. He reported the injury to his supervisor immediately. Believing that the injury was a minor strain, the plaintiff sought two or three treatments from a chiropractor, but his symptoms worsened. He was ultimately seen by Dr. Jerry Engelberg, a neurosurgeon. After an MRI was performed, Dr. Engelberg told the plaintiff that he had a tumor, an ependymoma, in his spine that had caused some spinal damage. According to the plaintiff's testimony, Dr. Engelberg told him he needed immediate surgery, because there was a risk that he might never walk again if he were to stumble or miss a step. After surgery was performed, the plaintiff received radiation and chemotherapy treatments under the supervision of an oncologist, Dr. Kirby Smith. At the time of the trial, the plaintiff still had complaints of low back cramps, difficulty 2

Victor Austin vs. Shelby Co. Govt.
02A01-9805-CH-00145
Trial Court Judge: C. Neal Small

John Ball vs. Missy Ball
02A01-9709-GS-00239
Trial Court Judge: Max Seaton

Antonio Sweatt vs. Donal Campbell
02A01-9808-CV-00227
Trial Court Judge: R. Lee Moore Jr.

Brashears vs. City Knoxvlle
03A01-9809-CV-00298

Scarlett vs. Oakes
03A01-9806-CH-00201

Lee vs. Zhao
03A01-9807-CH-00209

Brown vs. Brown
03A01-9806-CH-00178

Williams vs. Williams vs. Hay
01A01-9710-CV-00566

State vs. Gerald Henry
01C01-9505-CR-00161
Trial Court Judge: Seth W. Norman

In the matter of: Courtney Jade Canova
01A01-9803-JV-00113
Trial Court Judge: Andrew J. Shookhoff

State vs. John Hill
01C01-9802-CC-00072

Griffin vs. Shelter Mutual Ins. Co.
01A01-9712-CH-00700
Trial Court Judge: Carol L. Mccoy

State vs. Martin Jones
03C01-9803-CR-00084
Trial Court Judge: Lynn W. Brown

State vs. Wiliam Belser
03C01-9803-CR-00110
Trial Court Judge: Ray L. Jenkins

State vs. Woodrow Wilson Mounger
03C01-9802-CR-00081
Trial Court Judge: Phyllis H. Miller

State vs. Curtis Bolton
03C01-9707-CR-00255
Trial Court Judge: W. Lee Asbury

State vs. Nathaniel Allen
01C01-9804-CC-00164

Pass vs. Pass
03A01-9710-CV-00493
Trial Court Judge: W. Dale Young

Alexander vs. Sandpiper Properties
03A01-9804-CH-00125

State Farm Fire vs. Wood
03A01-9807-CH-00227

Midwest Bronze vs. Outlaw Aircraft Sales
01A01-9707-CH-00358
Trial Court Judge: Alex W. Darnell

Harry Conklin vs. State
01C01-9708-CR-00347

State vs. Ross Austin
01C01-9709-CR-00401

State vs. John Scales
01C01-9709-CR-00412