State of Tennessee v. Leonard Edward Smith
In this automatic appeal,1 the defendant, Leonard Edward Smith, raises numerous challenges to the decision of the Court of Criminal Appeals which affirmed his sentence of death for the 1984 murder of Novella Webb. After carefully examining the entire record and the law, including the thorough opinion of the Court of Criminal Appeals and the briefs of the defendant and the State, this Court entered an Order limiting review at oral argument to the following three issues:2 (1) Whether the trial court was correct in allowing the defendant to control the presentation of mitigating evidence and to waive closing argument against counsel’s advice; (2) Whether the admittance of victim impact testimony and argument at the sentencing hearing constituted reversible error; (3) Whether the sentence of death is arbitrary or disproportionate in violation of Tenn. Code Ann. § 39-13-206(c)(1)(A)-(D) (1997 Repl.). |
Hamblen | Supreme Court | |
State vs. Angela Titus
|
Marshall | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
01C01-9803-CR-00105
|
Davidson | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Marvin Woods
|
Hardeman | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. James A. Woods
|
Franklin | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Roderick S. Williams
|
Dickson | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Taniese A. Wilson
|
Coffee | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Lee Lance
|
McMinn | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Norman Sutton
|
Cocke | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Eric Dwayne McLemore
|
Hamilton | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Glenna Kidd
|
Wilson | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
Derrick Sawyers vs. State
|
Davidson | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
Edward C. Coker vs. State
|
Williamson | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
Henry vs. Metro Gov't
|
Davidson | Court of Appeals | |
Collins vs. Willis
|
Coffee | Court of Appeals | |
State vs. Robert D. Merritt, Jr.
|
Davidson | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
Cobble vs. Shewmake et al
|
Court of Appeals | ||
Grimes vs. Grimes
|
Maury | Court of Appeals | |
State vs.Robert A. Norris & Lida A. Meador
|
Cumberland | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Venson Terrell Taylor
|
Robertson | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Ricky Crawford
|
Shelby | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Ricky Crawford
|
Shelby | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Edward Drummer
|
Shelby | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Charles Justin Osborne
|
Perry | Court of Criminal Appeals | |
State vs. Kelly A. Hancock
|
Williamson | Court of Criminal Appeals |